children of asylum seekers
8 replies
Avatar
detrimentum
2015/02/12 13:10
Inquiry: Children in Australian immigration detention abused BY KRISTEN GELINEAU, ASSOCIATED PRESS February 12, 2015 SYDNEY — Australia's policy of indefinitely holding children of asylum seekers in immigration detention camps violates international laws, the government's human rights watchdog found, after an inquiry uncovered hundreds of reports of assaults involving child detainees. The head of Australia's Human Rights Commission called Thursday for the swift release of children from detention centers and demanded a royal commission — the nation's most powerful form of inquiry — into Australia's longstanding practice of mandatory detention for asylum seekers who travel to Australia by boat. "What is now required, we think, is a full royal commission into a policy that's been in existence for 23 years that has brought deep damage and despair and misery to thousands of children and their families," Human Rights Commission President Gillian Triggs said. "Australia is ashamed of this policy and we need a new road to deal with these problems." The government dismissed the commission's findings, with Prime Minister Tony Abbott dubbing the report "blatantly partisan." Immigration Minister Peter Dutton said in a statement that some of the report's recommendations would undermine "the very policies that mean children don't get on boats in the first place." Between January 2013 and March 2014, there were 233 assaults involving child detainees and 33 reported sexual assaults — the majority of which involved children. In that same period, 128 detained children tried to harm themselves, engaging in everything from self-cutting to swallowing insect repellent. More than a third of detained children suffer from mental health disorders. "I don't have any hope," one teenager detained on Christmas Island told the commission. "I feel I will die in detention." The commission wants the government to ban indefinite detention, close the "harsh and cramped" Christmas Island camp, get children off Nauru and appoint an independent guardian for unaccompanied minors. The report comes as little surprise, given that the commission held a similar inquiry a decade ago raising the same concerns: that children who spend a long time in detention are at high risk of serious mental harm, that mandatory detention of children violates international laws, that conditions in some camps are deplorably bad — unsanitary, unsafe, and unsuitable for children. Australia holds about 300 children in its mainland and offshore camps, down from a peak of about 2,000 in 2013. The nearly 120 being held on Nauru are suffering from "extreme levels" of physical, emotional, psychological and developmental distress, the commission found. "The Human Rights Commission ought to be ashamed of itself," Abbott told Fairfax Radio. "Where was the Human Rights Commission when hundreds of people were drowning at sea?" Asked if he felt any guilt about the treatment of children in detention, Abbott replied: "None whatsoever."
Avatar
jaQui
2015/02/12 13:33
They are not human, very cruel and sadistic
Avatar
Xiao Zen
2015/02/12 13:38
I do not believe these policies will change in the immediate future. Perhaps it is cynical of me but it would seem to me that conditions are as bad as they are to discourage asylum seekers from seeking it in Australia. It is a time of great instability, this forces many to seek refuge outside their own countries. Many nations are feeling the weight of the burden of sheltering refugees, some bear the burden well in spite of this while other do not.
Avatar
detrimentum
2015/02/12 13:40
jacki: They are not human, very cruel and sadistic
They think they are tolerant people though... Yet its clear that they arent.
Avatar
detrimentum
2015/02/12 13:44
Opium: I do not believe these policies will change in the immediate future. Perhaps it is cynical of me but the it would seem to me that conditions are as bad as they are to discourage asylum seekers from seeking it in Australia. It is a time of great instability, this forces many to seek refuge outside their countries. Many nations are feeling the weight of the burden of sheltering refugees, some bear the burden well in spite of this while other do not.
its children... In my opinion that's all they should be labeled as. Not refugees, asylum seekers or immigrants.... Children. And this from a ''civilized'' country. Bloody disgusting I tell you.... Being oppressed by islam while opressing children without guilt.... How does that work?
Avatar
Xiao Zen
2015/02/12 22:22
ethereal: its children... In my opinion that's all they should be labeled as. Not refugees, asylum seekers or immigrants.... Children. And this from a ''civilized'' country. Bloody disgusting I tell you.... Being oppressed by islam while opressing children without guilt.... How does that work?
It is disgusting and ideally they should just be thought of as children nothing more or less, this is true, however they are not Australian children and to some people the distinction matters. I do not mean to suggest that all Australians are this way, that would neither be fair nor accurate but Australian society in general needs to ask itself some hard and frank questions, this much I will say.
Avatar
TemPEST
2015/02/12 22:33
Everyone is blasting Australia which i think is wrong. Where in the world illegal immigrants dont get jailed be it children/adult while Australia is being lambasted what are the leaders of the said children country get at least being in detention is better than drowning
Avatar
detrimentum
2015/02/13 06:44
TemPEST: Everyone is blasting Australia which i think is wrong. Where in the world illegal immigrants dont get jailed be it children/adult while Australia is being lambasted what are the leaders of the said children country get at least being in detention is better than drowning
Detention isn't the problem. The conditions of the detention is the problem....you can detain illegal immigrants, its your right as a country, but according to international law you are not allowed to abuse them so severely that they become mentally ill and suicidal. And you should make sure no child is sexually abused while in your custody. How hard is that? they can put them on the next available boat and send them back home if they wish... But instead they detain them on an island. If their country cared about them they wouldn't be taking the risk of detention in a foreign country. South Africa is a funny little country ( see SONA 2015. lol) but even our government doesn't do this... america sends them home without abusing their children... Canada, one of the strictest countries regarding immigration just sends them home... because its inhumane to detain people and children in such a manner... They are nothing but captors of children who had no choice but to go with their parents. So australia has absolutely no reason or excuse for their actions.
Avatar
NinthElement
2015/02/19 03:30
The Australian government's whole attitude towards asylum seekers is consistently mean-spirited, and such ugly policies that fail to treat even children as innocent victims seem purposely designed to demonstrate that uncharitable standpoint. The strong have a responsibility to protect the helpless.
#2 General Area
A forum for life in general. Post about news, social matters, relationships, lifestyle, or anything on your mind.
Forums
Home