Quote:
outlaw:
Can you be specific about those laws? Because not all Muslim dominated countries use a strictly sharia-based code. For example, decriminalization of homosexuality would certainly be a violation of islam. As for the "general conduct of muslims", I'll go back to my death penalty analogy. As long as we have executioners willing to kill people for us, we don't need to get our hands dirty. To expand on this analogy, some people even say "we don't like this, but it's necessary in the eyes of god", and some people get even more ridiculous and shrug off all responsibility by saying "those dirty fornicators punish themselves!".
Besides, the question of how many people follow the instructions says nothing about the instructions themselves. I'm sure plenty of muslims drink and still identify themselves as muslims for all intents and purposes. Nobody asks for reinstatement of slavery, even though the quran allows it (by your own admission). So there are clearly discrepancies in instructions and people's general conduct.
So I'll go back to my question of what the text actually contains, besides the slavery thing. Does it or does it not criminalize non-criminal behaviors like homosexuality, apostasy, blasphemy, adultery, etc and prescribe stoning, flogging, death etc as punishments for these?
The narrower your focus the less you see around you Tanuki, you're so focused on that one point that you're not seeing the dozens more that counter it. Your death penalty analogy while not completely wrong in theory has no measurable variables, its neither here nor there, it simply states a possibility that cannot be proved. Our conduct is however measurable.