"Response no 1" to, "top 10 Controversial verses o by Musafir 2013/06/17 08:57
I saw this topic with total mentally copy paste, and on my request to close the topic, it's still in forums, thats y i am trying to clear all doubs of an anti Islamic minds.
Top 10 Controversial verses of Quran
In this topic creator has mentioned many points regarding Islamic contradictions, and let me clear it one by one making topics.
Objection number 1 -A Man may marry four wives.
Lets see what Islam says actually about this matter :)
Qur’an is
the only religious book on the
face of the earth that says ‘marry
only one’. The context of this
phrase is the following verse
from Surah Nisa of the Glorious Qur’an: “Marry women of your
choice, two, or three, or
four; but if ye fear that
ye shall not be able to
deal justly (with them),
then only one.†[Al- Qur’an 4:3] Before the Qur’an was revealed,
there was no upper limit for
polygyny and many men had
scores of wives, some even
hundreds. Islam put an upper
limit of four wives. Islam gives a man permission to marry two,
three or four women, only on
the condition that he deals justly
with them. In the same chapter i.e. Surah
Nisa verse 129 says: “Ye are never able
to be fair and just as between
women….†[Al-Qur’an
4:129
Now we will see what Hindu scriptures says in this matter and was this act of having more wives legal in Hindu scriptures.
Polygamy In Hinduism According to the
scriptures, a Hindu
marriage is indissolvable in life. Still
polygamy was rampantly practised in
ancient Hindu society. An address by
Bhishma to King Yudhishthira in the Mahabharata, succinctly endorses this
fact:
A Brahmana can take three wives. A Kshatriya can take two wives.
As regards the Vaishya, he should
take a wife from only his own order.
The children born of these wives should be regarded as
equal." (Anusasana Parva, Section
XLIV). But now that polygamy has
been completely gutted out by law,
monogamy is the only option for
Hindus.
INTERESTING NOTE
(interesting Note:- As per the
1975 census of India Hindus are
more polygynous than Muslims.
The report of the ‘Committee of
The Status of Woman in Islam’,
published in 1975 mentions on page numbers 66 and 67 that
the percentage of polygamous
marriages between the years
1951 and 1961 was 5.06%
among the Hindus and only
4.31 % among the Muslims. According to Indian law only
Muslim men are permitted to
have more than one wife. It is
illegal for any non-Muslim in
India to have more than one
wife. Despite it being illegal, Hindus have more multiple
wives as compared to Muslims.
Earlier, there was no restriction
even on Hindu men with respect
to the number of wives allowed.
It was only in 1954, when the Hindu Marriage Act was passed
that it became illegal for a Hindu
to have more than one wife. At
present it is the Indian Law that
restricts a Hindu man from
having more than one wife and not the Hindu scriptures.
Now go and search both Islamic sites on google to quote me, but my topic is not provocative but just a response to above topic, it's a start me one objection, many topics are soon going to come in highlights.
I saw this topic with total mentally copy paste, and on my request to close the topic, it's still in forums, thats y i am trying to clear all doubs of an anti Islamic minds.
Top 10 Controversial verses of Quran
In this topic creator has mentioned many points regarding Islamic contradictions, and let me clear it one by one making topics.
Objection number 1 -A Man may marry four wives.
Lets see what Islam says actually about this matter :)
Qur’an is
the only religious book on the
face of the earth that says ‘marry
only one’. The context of this
phrase is the following verse
from Surah Nisa of the Glorious Qur’an: “Marry women of your
choice, two, or three, or
four; but if ye fear that
ye shall not be able to
deal justly (with them),
then only one.†[Al- Qur’an 4:3] Before the Qur’an was revealed,
there was no upper limit for
polygyny and many men had
scores of wives, some even
hundreds. Islam put an upper
limit of four wives. Islam gives a man permission to marry two,
three or four women, only on
the condition that he deals justly
with them. In the same chapter i.e. Surah
Nisa verse 129 says: “Ye are never able
to be fair and just as between
women….†[Al-Qur’an
4:129
Now we will see what Hindu scriptures says in this matter and was this act of having more wives legal in Hindu scriptures.
Polygamy In Hinduism According to the
scriptures, a Hindu
marriage is indissolvable in life. Still
polygamy was rampantly practised in
ancient Hindu society. An address by
Bhishma to King Yudhishthira in the Mahabharata, succinctly endorses this
fact:
A Brahmana can take three wives. A Kshatriya can take two wives.
As regards the Vaishya, he should
take a wife from only his own order.
The children born of these wives should be regarded as
equal." (Anusasana Parva, Section
XLIV). But now that polygamy has
been completely gutted out by law,
monogamy is the only option for
Hindus.
INTERESTING NOTE
(interesting Note:- As per the
1975 census of India Hindus are
more polygynous than Muslims.
The report of the ‘Committee of
The Status of Woman in Islam’,
published in 1975 mentions on page numbers 66 and 67 that
the percentage of polygamous
marriages between the years
1951 and 1961 was 5.06%
among the Hindus and only
4.31 % among the Muslims. According to Indian law only
Muslim men are permitted to
have more than one wife. It is
illegal for any non-Muslim in
India to have more than one
wife. Despite it being illegal, Hindus have more multiple
wives as compared to Muslims.
Earlier, there was no restriction
even on Hindu men with respect
to the number of wives allowed.
It was only in 1954, when the Hindu Marriage Act was passed
that it became illegal for a Hindu
to have more than one wife. At
present it is the Indian Law that
restricts a Hindu man from
having more than one wife and not the Hindu scriptures.
Now go and search both Islamic sites on google to quote me, but my topic is not provocative but just a response to above topic, it's a start me one objection, many topics are soon going to come in highlights.
Musafir 2013/06/17 09:07
whoever have objection on my copy paste shall object on that topic first which is not closed and alive in forum.
whoever have objection on my copy paste shall object on that topic first which is not closed and alive in forum.
Zayeedat0 2013/06/21 14:39
thanks for ur post and research bro, Allah (swt) warned us abt justification and equality and which he (allah) know that is the one that can do it not human being
thanks for ur post and research bro, Allah (swt) warned us abt justification and equality and which he (allah) know that is the one that can do it not human being
Rebellion 2013/06/29 16:20
Hahaha... ur contradicting yourself now...I have seen you and your friends saying: Hurray! Muslims are allowed to have 3 or more wives And hindus not That's why rapes are happening in India
And you are just accepting the first Verse by the help of this...
“Marry women of your
choice, two, or three, or
four; but if ye fear that
ye shall not be able to
deal justly (with them),
then only one.â€
No need to say more
You're free to accept the rest also
Hahaha... ur contradicting yourself now...I have seen you and your friends saying: Hurray! Muslims are allowed to have 3 or more wives And hindus not That's why rapes are happening in India
And you are just accepting the first Verse by the help of this...
“Marry women of your
choice, two, or three, or
four; but if ye fear that
ye shall not be able to
deal justly (with them),
then only one.â€
No need to say more
You're free to accept the rest also
Rebellion 2013/06/29 16:27
And tell you what....Internet is full of Islamic responses Which is laughable, It shows that how desperate muslims are, to justify their assumptions.
Tell you one thing, this world doesn't function over few written text, Today people are more educated and aware than in the past times And they need visual facts Not imaginary ones
And tell you what....Internet is full of Islamic responses Which is laughable, It shows that how desperate muslims are, to justify their assumptions.
Tell you one thing, this world doesn't function over few written text, Today people are more educated and aware than in the past times And they need visual facts Not imaginary ones
#78 Faith/Beliefs
Share your views and beliefs on religion, theology, culture and matters of faith.